Fonds AH1092 - Garment Workers Union records

Identity area

Reference code

ZA HPRA AH1092

Title

Garment Workers Union records

Date(s)

  • 1918 - 1976 (Creation)

Level of description

Fonds

Extent and medium

Context area

Name of creator

Administrative history

The first successful attempt to organise workers in the clothing industry was the formation of the Witwatersrand Tailors Association in 1918. This period in the history of the union is characterised by its attempts to stamp out 'sweated labour' and the systems of contracting and piecework, and to improve working conditions. The union was divided into two sections, the bespoke and the factory. An attempt was also made to ensure that employers and manufacturers adhered to log prices and did not underpay workers in order to be competitive.

After the strike of 1922, the government introduced machinery to regulate relations between workers and employers. This was the beginning of an attempt at conciliation which was later much championed by the leaders of the Garment Workers Union. The Industrial Conciliation Act was passed in 1924 and the Garment Workers Union was one of the first to be registered. With the formation of the Industrial Council for the Bespoke Tailoring Industry in 1928 and then the Industrial Council for the Clothing Industry, the union became party to both councils

The union's membership was not confined to the Witwatersrand, but was extended to Bloemfontein where a branch was established by the Secretary, Cecil Frank Glass, in 1926. The members were mostly older males, many of them Jewish tailors who had emigrated from Eastern Europe to South Africa. During this period there were a number of individual strikes by workers against their 'rat employers'.

The Witwatersrand Tailors Association was active in promoting a trade union federation in South Africa, supporting first the South African Industrial Federation, and then, during its decline in 1922, the formation of ATUSA (Associated Trade Unions of South Africa) which later became SATUC (South African Trade Union Congress). The active leaders included M Baum, D Colraine, C F Glass, H Joseph and A F Tuffin.

The election of Emil Solomon 'Solly' Sachs as General Secretary on 14 November 1928 heralded a new era for the union. Sachs and his thinking dominated all its activities until 1952. He came to South Africa from Latvia at the end of 1913 or the beginning of 1914 (Sachs gives conflicting dates in various biographical accounts). He attended school until 1916, then worked in a bookshop and later in mine shops on the Witwatersrand. In 1919 he was active in the Reef Shop Assistants Union which agitated for shorter hours. According to Sachs' own testimony, he had to leave the trade as he was marked as an agitator, but he continued as Honorary Secretary of the union. In 1924 he enrolled at the University of the Witwatersrand for an engineering degree, but had to discontinue his studies because of insufficient means. He first came into contact with garment workers when he was elected Secretary of the Witwatersrand Middlemen Tailors Association on 31 March 1927. He subsequently became the General Secretary of the Witwatersrand Tailors Association.

In July 1929 a new constitution for the union was adopted, the name being changed to the Garment Workers Union, although the name was actually only adopted in 1930. There were 1750 members, two thirds of them factory workers

Sachs immediately tackled the problem of the violation of the agreements of both the Industrial Council for the Bespoke Tailoring Industry and the Industrial Council for the Clothing Industry (Transvaal). He started examining wage registers and prosecuting employers, many of whom were paying irregularly and forcing workers to sign for wages which they had not received. Sachs firmly believed in the law in South Africa and in the following years the Garment Workers Union made much use of the courts to bring employers and enemies of the union to justice.

The union suffered a severe setback in the early 1930s in its fight for better wages. In 1931 there use a general strike which ended inconclusively and left the workers whose earnings were meagre and inadequate in no better position. In 1932 there was another strike of garment workers as a result of demands by employers to reduce wages

Mr Oswald Pirow, then Minister of Justice, took a hard line and used the police force against the strikers. The workers were defeated although the employers achieved only a 10% reduction in wages, compared to their original demand for 25%. Sachs was served with a deportation order which was never enforced, although he was not allowed to live on the Witwatersrand for twelve months. Between 1928 and 1932 there were 100 strikes which to some extent helped to improve conditions or end grievances. In 1934 the bespoke section of the union was dissolved and the tailors formed the Tailoring Workers Industrial Union (Transvaal).

The 1930s and 1940s saw the blossoming of Afrikaner nationalism, and the National Party made a concerted effort to destroy the union which had attracted so many of their people. In 1935 a closed shop clause was included in the agreement. These were also the years which saw the rise and zenith of Fascism in Europe. Fascist groups such as the Greyshirts and Blackshirts used racist ideology to attack the union.

Anti-Semitism was also on the upswing and Sachs was repeatedly accused of being a 'Communist Jew'. It says much for Sachs and the personal loyalty of the workers: towards him, that the union did not succumb. He openly fought back and from 1939 he won a number of defamation cases against the Afrikaans press who were supported by the Nederduits Hervormde Kerk van Afrika. A very bitter struggle was waged in the Germiston branch where the National Party Member for Parliament, Johannes du Pisanie, was active in inciting the workers. The 1940's were a period of bitter struggles for fair wages as also of feuding between the Transvaal garment workers and Cape workers, led by Robert Stuart, who was bitterly opposed to national unity among garment workers

In 1948 the union obtained a forty hour week for the workers

The passing of the Suppression of Communism Act in 1950 caused another crisis in the history of the Union. Its leaders Anna Scheepers (President), Sachs (General Secretary) and Johanna Cornelius were listed as Communists. Sachs appealed on the grounds that he had been a member of the Communist Party from 1921 until August 1931 when he had been expelled from the party for political differences. Subsequently he supported the South African Labour Party. Sachs' banning meant that he could no longer hold his position as General Secretary of the Garment Workers Union, nor could he attend public gatherings

Sachs flagrantly disobeyed these orders by addressing a mass meeting of garment workers on 24 May 1952. He was supported by all the workers who again convened on 26 May after his arrest and condemned his listing as a Communist and his removal from the secretaryship of the Garment Workers Union.

Sachs' position eventually became so intolerable to him, that he left South Africa and settled in England. He died in London in 1976.

Over the years the composition of the union had changed. Whereas in 1938 Coloured workers were 22% of the total membership, by 1953 the union comprised 60% Coloured workers to 40% White. By law the union had had to establish parallel branches, No.1 branches being for Whites and No.2 branches for Coloureds. This has now been reversed and once again the Garment Workers Union is allowed to have combined branches

Johanna Catharina Cornelius Fellner succeeded Sachs as General Secretary and served in this capacity until her death on 21 June 1974. In the first few years of his exile Sachs attempted to continue his fight for the workers in South Africa but lack of support from the Garment Workers Union caused his efforts to peter out. In general this was a quiet period of co-operation and negotiation. It was influenced by the Botha Commission (Industrial Legislation Commission) set up in 1945, and the passing of the Natives (Settlements of Disputes) Act and the Industrial Conciliation Act of 1956. There was a split in the ranks of the union, as the White workers felt that the provisions of the Industrial Conciliation Act would make it impossible for racially mixed unions to operate. They thus formed the Garment Trade Union of European Employees (SA). Other problems to which the union paid attention were job reservation, workers in uncontrolled areas, and the establishment of a training college for garment workers

Another outstanding leader of the union was Anna Elizabeth Scheepers. Born on 18 March 1914 on the farm De la Rey near Krugersdorp, she attended Monument High School but was obliged to leave school in her matriculation year as her family had been severely affected by the depression. In 1933 she started work as a presser in a Johannesburg factory and began to be active in the activities of the Garment Workers Union. In August 1935 she was elected President of the union. Like other trade unionists of the time she visited Russia before the war and C R Swart attempted to list her as a Communist in 1952. She has distinguished herself, receiving a medal for voluntary services in World War II from Field Marshal J C Smuts. In November 1968 she was elected as the first and only woman on the General Council of the International Textile, Garment and Leather Workers Federation. In April 1973 she was awarded the Honorary degree of Doctor of Laws by the University of the Witwatersrand and in 1974 she was elected a Senator.

Besides the struggle for fair wages and a shorter working week, the union was able to obtain for the workers by 1949 three weeks' paid annual leave, whereas in 1928 there had been no such paid leave. In 1928 the only paid holidays were Christmas Day and May Day. In 1949 four other public holidays were added. By creating funds, two important social services were provided namely assistance to the sick and unemployed.

The Garment Workers Union struggled in order to obtain a better life for its members, relying almost entirely on its own strength and the moral support of fellow trade unionists. The union was respected by some employers and feared by others, but its members were treated with respect as they always had recourse to it if they were being mistreated.

Archival history

Immediate source of acquisition or transfer

Content and structure area

Scope and content

The records of the Garment Workers Union were acquired by the University of the Witwatersrand in the first half of 1977. They originally consisted of about 1150 files and boxes as well as several large cartons of miscellaneous documents. This rich hoard represents one of the best documented histories of a trade union in South Africa and spans the years 1915 to the present. The records of the Garment Workers Union 1 complement the records of TUCSA (Trade Union Council of South Africa) and also form the core of a documentation project to record the history of the industrialisation of South Africa.

The records document the activities of the union which initially included both garment workers and bespoke tailors. They record the history of the struggle on behalf of the workers for fair wages and the attempt to combat underpayment and unfair dismissal by employers; the fight against contracting and piecework; acceptable hours of work and working conditions; recruitment of members and the appeal to workers to support the trade union in order to improve their lot; collective bargaining with the employers' associations in order to draw up mutually acceptable agreements; relationship of the Witwatersrand Tailors Association and Garment Workers Union with such trade union federations as South African Industrial Federation (SAIF), Cape Federation of Labour Unions, South African Trades and Labour Council and TUCSA; relationship with the government - in particular the Department of Labour and the Wage Board; organising of the union, discipline of members, help to members such as providing loan funds, welfare services, sick benefits and medical aid; financing of the union; the registration of branches in Johannesburg, Pretoria, the East Rand, Orange Free State and the Cape; strikes, including the miners' strike of 1913 and 1922; fostering of race relations (as a large percentage of garment workers were Coloureds); the struggle for unity and the attempt to create a united union for all garment workers in South Africa; industrial conciliation; the threat of Afrikaner nationalism to the unity and very existence of the union (the majority of the workers were Afrikaners); the Commission of Inquiry into the Garment Workers Union in 1949; support of political parties such as the South African Labour Party and the Communist Party of South Africa; the Suppression of Communism Act and the threatened listing of the leaders of the union leading to the eventual departure of Solly Sachs from South Africa; the activities of Solly Sachs, Johanna Cornelius and Anna Scheepers; the fight against the Blankewerkersbeskermingsbond.

The records are in English and Afrikaans with some odd correspondence in Yiddish (many of the tailors wore Jewish immigrants from Eastern Europe). In the description of Afrikaans documents the spelling in use at the time has been followed. The union was multi-racial consisting of Whites, Coloureds and Indians. Branches were kept separate, No.1 branches being for Whites and No.2 branches for Coloureds. Throughout the inventory, the apostrophe denoting the possessive form in the case of all trade unions has been dropped, e.g. Sweet Workers Union.

I would like to acknowledge the help of those officials of the Garment Workers Union who gave me their time and offered me inside information about the union which was not recorded in the records, in particular Ms Fay Mandy and Mr Andrew Unsworth. I would also like to express my gratitude to the researchers who used the documents while they were being processed, and who drew my attention to information which I would otherwise have missed in so vast a collection. To the students Brian Cutler and Lesley Dean, who helped me sort the documents and who patiently bore with experimental methods of sorting and arrangement of the records, my sincere thanks.

Marcelle Jacobson November 1950.

In 1948 a commission of enquiry was appointed to examine the affairs of the Garment Workers Union. From this time onwards Sachs was personally harassed, his passport being withdrawn on 20 May 1949, which prevented him from attending the International Conference of Garment and Textile Trade Unions that year. Sachs refused to surrender the passport and the Minister of Justice, Dr T E Donges, appealed to the Supreme Court, but Sachs eventually won the appeal.

Appraisal, destruction and scheduling

Accruals

System of arrangement

On acquisition the records had to be arranged according to archival type. The vast size of the collection required a different method of processing to that previously used for other collections. The most important principle to be established was the arrangement of the records in such a way as to reflect the administrative organisation of the union. By this means the original order of the files could be ascertained rather than the order in which they ware received by the University. At first glance the records did not reveal an internal filing system and this was confirmed by union officials. Although most files were labelled, there was no indication of relationships between files

The first task was a survey of the contents of the files and their appraisal. All the files and boxes were numbered and a shelf list card was made for each file listing its temporary number, title (which in many cases did not reflect its contents), the approximate years it covered and a brief description of its contents. Notes were also made on whether multiple copies of documents were to be discarded later, irrelevant or misfiled documents were to be refiled, as well as cross references to other files which contained similar material. Nevertheless, the basic principle of preserving the integrity of each file, where possible, was adhered to when sorting the files at the later stages. The preliminary survey took approximately nine months to complete.

During this time several researchers were using the documents. Some had had previous access to them while still in the possession of the Garment Workers Union, while others were writing theses on the activities of the union and had to have access to the records. As the sorting of the documents would take a few years, it was felt unfair to embargo the records completely. Those files which had been processed in the preliminary stage were made available and access to their contents was facilitated by the use of the shelf list cards

Once this task was completed, a further three months were spent on drawing up a classification scheme, based on the contents of the files. The records revealed five main areas of activity of the Garment Workers Union:

  1. Witwatersrand Tailors Association (the predecessor of the Garment Workers Union)

  2. internal organisation and management of the Garment Workers Union

  3. relationship between the Garment Workers Union and the clothing industry

  4. Garment Workers Union activities in the trade union movement and labour economies

  5. the relationship between the Garment Workers Union and the government.

1 See: Inventories of Collections, No.7

The final sorting of the documents was done according to this classification. Initially the shelf list cards (formerly filed in numerical order) were assigned a classification number and refiled accordingly. The formidable size of the collection made it impossible for one professional person to sort single-handed. Since much of the work was clerical and involved sorting into chronological order, recording of the minutes and labelling files and boxes, two students were employed on a part-time basis. The actual sorting of the records began in mid-1978.

One of the first problems to be faced was the vast amount of duplication in the files. Whereas many trade unions have unfortunately thrown out valuable records, the Garment Workers Union zealously hoarded all documents. This problem was not much in evidence in the earlier records, but from the 1950s, when duplicating machines were first used, it was not unusual to find up to thirty copies of a document in the same file. In addition in many cases, copies of documents were filed in more than one file. It was decided that, as space was at a premium and as the aim of an archive is permanent preservation, only one copy of a document per file would be kept (this same rule did not always apply where the original manuscript version and the typewritten document were available). This decision enabled the bulk of the collection to be reduced by at least one third.

There was also no organised record of the minutes of the various committees and branches. Many were scattered and interfiled in general correspondence files. All minutes were therefore extracted from such files and a complete record was made for the department.

I was able to sort and describe sections A and B, but unfortunately I was unable to see the project through to its conclusion. Sections C-E were sorted by Anna N Cunningham.

As the original arrangement in the files has been adhered to where possible, to a large extent like subjects are scattered throughout the records. As this collection forms part of a larger documentation project, a thesaurus of trade union and labour economic terms was compiled and has been used to index this collection as well as the records of TUCSA. All references in the index are to the clothing industry unless otherwise stated. (Note: index not included in the Internet version of this inventory).

Conditions of access and use area

Conditions governing access

Conditions governing reproduction

Language of material

Script of material

Language and script notes

Physical characteristics and technical requirements

Finding aids

Allied materials area

Existence and location of originals

Existence and location of copies

Related units of description

Related descriptions

Notes area

Alternative identifier(s)

Access points

Subject access points

Place access points

Name access points

Genre access points

Description control area

Description identifier

Institution identifier

Rules and/or conventions used

Status

Level of detail

Dates of creation revision deletion

Language(s)

Script(s)

Sources

Archivist's note

Compiled by Marcelle Jacobson and Anna M Cunningham

Accession area

Related subjects

Related people and organizations

Related genres

Related places